Why Chemistry Often Takes a Backseat: A Personal Insight and Comparison with Math and Physics

I have always found myself drawn to the beauty and elegance of mathematics and physics. These disciplines offer a distinct charm, from the abstract theories of quantum mechanics to the intricate equations of tensor calculus. But there's something equally captivating about chemistry, especially the hands-on, experimental adventures it presents.

The Overlooked Brilliance of Chemistry

Chemistry, to many, is often eclipsed by the towering figures of mathematics and physics. Yet, chemistry is as fascinating as these giants are. Consider the late, notorious Heisenberg, the namesake of the Uncertainty Principle. Sure, there's the infamous depiction of him cooking meth, but in my mind, he is a symbol of the intrigue and complexity that chemistry embodies. Even a not-so-respectable figure like this can highlight the allure of the subject.

Why Chemistry Makes Sense to Me

What drew me to chemistry was its logicality. Unlike mathematics, which can delve into the arcane and esoteric (like tensors, studied only by a few), or physics, which has its own profound abstractions, chemistry provides a relatively straightforward progression. In my school years, I found myself quickly grasping how molecules interact, and soon understanding how complex compounds can be built from simpler ones. This kind of step-by-step comprehension was and is appealing to me.

While both mathematics and physics offer a similar progression, the journey through chemistry seemed smoother and more logical to me. There’s a tangible sense of accomplishment in reaching the end of a chemical formula or the completion of a lab experiment.

Conceptual Thinking and the Joy of Problem Solving

At the core of my appreciation for chemistry is the concept of creating and understanding things. Unlike mathematics and physics, which often require a deep theoretical background and complex abstractions, chemistry offers a more hands-on and experimental approach that resonates with my love for the analytical and cerebral problem-solving. For me, pure mathematics and physics are tools for training the mind to think in abstract terms, which can then be applied to real-world problems or used as engaging puzzles.

In chemistry, there is a balance of theory and application. However, at my current institution, the learning experience is more focused on memorization rather than understanding. For instance, during my first semester, I had to memorize common solubility rules, only to be introduced to the theoretical principles in the following semesters. In both physics and mathematics, we start with theory and work toward practical applications, making the learning process more intuitive and less about rote memorization.

Philosophy of Learning and Problem Solving

I began in philosophy, where I developed a deeper appreciation for abstract thinking and theory. While I enjoy lab work and the fun of experimental chemistry, my inclination is toward theory. Chemistry, to me, can be deeply enjoyable and intellectually stimulating, but often, it requires memorization of trivial facts and models, which I find less engaging.

What I Enjoy in Chemistry

Despite the challenges, there are aspects of chemistry that I find incredibly rewarding. Concepts like Lewis dot structures, VSEPR theory, quantum mechanics, and dimensional analysis are not just memorization exercises but fundamental to understanding the behavior and interactions of molecules. When provided with a model and data, I relish the challenge of solving problems. These topics are based on rules that define a system, and when explained properly, the complexity becomes quite intuitive.

While I accept that there are instances where memorization is required, I strongly advocate for a more theoretical and problem-solving approach. By understanding the underlying principles, the need for rote memorization diminishes.

Final Thoughts

Ultimately, the key to a fulfilling chemistry education lies in a balance between theoretical understanding and practical application. While chemistry may be overshadowed by the majesties of mathematics and physics, its intrinsic logic and problem-solving content offer unique opportunities for intellectual and practical growth. As someone who values both theory and application, I hope that chemistry can receive the recognition it deserves.