Understanding When Your Drawing Is Not Realistic

The question of whether your drawing is realistic can be complex and nuanced. In the art industry, 'realistic' can have multiple interpretations. Some artists and teachers believe that only the realism art style is valuable, emphasizing it in academic settings. However, it is essential to understand that realism is just one form of artistic expression, and there is much more to art than one style.

Contextualizing Realism in Art

Some art teachers and critics may insist that realism is the only true form of art. This belief is often propagated to maintain a certain control over the art community. While it is understandable that they have passionate opinions, it is crucial to recognize that their views are not universally accepted or accurate. Throughout history, diverse art styles have been celebrated, such as abstract, surreal, and expressionistic, which often surpass realism in terms of emotional depth and creativity.

Ignoring Unrealistic Criticism

If the person giving you feedback about the realism of your drawings is not your teacher, you should not let their opinions guide your artistic path. They may have their reasons for preferring realism, but their interests might not align with yours. It is better to focus on what you want to achieve and what resonates with your artistic vision.

Addressing Technical Realism

There are two primary contexts in which someone might comment on the realism of your drawings: the technical level of detail and proportions.

Level of Detail and Shading

One common critique is that drawings do not appear to have the necessary depth and detail. For instance, a 3D object might look two-dimensional due to poor shading. This is a valid concern, as detailed and well-crafted shading can significantly enhance the realism of your drawings. It is essential to pay attention to such feedback, as improving your shading techniques will make your artwork more appealing and professional.

Proportions and Perspective

Proportions are another crucial aspect of realistic drawing. Understanding and accurately depicting human proportions is particularly challenging, leading many artists to rely on skeletal and muscular models. However, it is important to recognize that proportionate drawing is not always necessary for all art forms. For example, in animation, comic art, and stylized character design, proportions can be exaggerated or altered to serve the narrative or stylistic needs.

Realism in proportions is vital for certain types of art, such as portraits or still life, where accuracy is crucial. In other cases, such as in cartooning, exaggeration can be more effective in conveying character and emotion. Learning the foundational principles of proportion will provide you with the tools to manipulate them as needed, allowing you to achieve a balanced and impactful result in your artwork.

Evaluating Criticism from Others

Not all critiques are created equal. It is important to assess the context and the specific feedback you receive. If someone suggests that your drawings are not realistic, consider whether they are criticizing the style or the technical aspects. If it is the latter, taking their advice can be beneficial for your growth as an artist.

Whose Opinion Matters?

Your opinion should ultimately dictate the direction of your art. If you discover that the feedback you receive aligns with your artistic goals, it might be helpful to take it into consideration. However, if you feel that someone is pressuring you into a certain style, it is essential to maintain your artistic integrity and focus on the style that feels authentic to you.

Conclusion

The realm of realism in art is vast and multifaceted. While realism can be a powerful style, it is just one among many. Understanding the context of the critique and assessing its validity can help you grow as an artist without compromising your unique voice. Embrace the diverse forms of expression and let your creativity thrive in the process.