The Decision Behind Choosing a Musical Instrument: Insights and Personal Stories

Choosing a musical instrument is a deeply personal decision, influenced by various factors such as personal interests, influence from others, accessibility, physical fit, and musical goals. This article explores these factors and shares some personal stories to illustrate the process of selecting a musical instrument.

Common Factors Influencing the Choice of Musical Instruments

These days, many people are drawn to an instrument because of its unique sound or the music it’s associated with. Others are inspired by friends, family members, or favorite musicians to pick a specific instrument. Additionally, the accessibility of the instrument in terms of availability and lessons in the local area can play a significant role. Some instruments may also be easier to handle or more comfortable for a person's physical attributes like size or hand strength. Lastly, a person's musical aspirations—such as playing in a band, orchestra, or as a solo artist—can guide their choice.

In reality, most people don't have a preconceived notion about which instrument they will play. Instead, they often test out different instruments and are told which one best suits them, especially in the case of wind instruments. For example, music shops can provide guidance on the best instrument for individuals based on their preferences and physical characteristics.

A Personal Story: Flute vs. Trumpet

Take the case of a student who joined the school band out of curiosity in 6th grade. For most of their childhood, they had always wanted to be a trumpet player. However, when it was time to choose their instrument at the beginning of the school year, they had an unexpected change of heart. The night before, they researched the flute and became wildly obsessed with it. Despite wanting to try the trumpet, they erased "Trumpet" from their paper and wrote "flute" instead. The flute turned out to be a challenging choice for them, but the inspiration from their interest in the instrument drove them to continue improving.

Motivations and Challenges in Choosing the Guitar

Another example comes from someone who originally wanted to learn the guitar due to their step-dad's influence. Then, the inspiration shifted to Yngwie Malmsteen, Paul Gilbert, and Jason Becker, leading them to want to "shred." Eventually, playing Dream Theater and mastering technical musicianship became the driving force behind their choice. The fun aspect of learning music they were genuinely interested in made the journey more enjoyable and fulfilling. As they deepened their engagement with the instrument, their playing matured, and they developed a desire to learn more complex and challenging music.

Conclusion

Choosing a musical instrument is a journey that involves exploration, interest, and a willingness to face challenges. Whether it’s inspired by personal curiosity, the influence of others, or a desire for technical mastery, the decision is often a blend of various factors. These stories highlight the diversity of paths people take in their musical journeys and the importance of finding an instrument that aligns with one's interests and aspirations.