Should NFL Commanders Prioritize a Quarterback in the 2023 Draft?

The 2023 NFL Draft stands as a critical juncture for every team eyeing a quarterback (QB) touchdown. The Washington Commanders are no exception, especially considering the potential of selecting a QB in the upcoming draft. However, the decision to pursue a QB in this year's draft is a double-edged sword, reflecting the broader challenges and business dynamics of the NFL.

Top Quarterback Options Relying on Draft Pick Status

Other teams, such as the Pittsburgh Steelers, Atlanta Falcons, and San Francisco 49ers, are also leaning on their respective QBs from the 2022 NFL Draft. This trend underscores a key consideration: a QB's draft position often dictates their potential for extended playing time.

QB Kenny Pickett, a first-round pick at 20th overall, demonstrated performance improvements throughout his rookie season, albeit with some mixed results. Similarly, Desmond Ridder, a third-round pick at 74th overall, showed consistent growth and improvement. Despite their early-round draft picks, both Pickett and Ridder will receive longer opportunities due to their draft status, a reality that NFL front offices strategize around.

In a similar vein, Brock Purdy, a seventh-round pick at 262nd overall, delivered outstanding performances in his rookie season, earning him more prominent playing time. However, even Purdy's successful stint was a result of his skill and performance, rather than any inherent guarantee due to his lower draft status.

The Case for Sam Howell

Sam Howell, a 2022 fifth-round pick, presents a different scenario. While he was undeniably a compelling find, his draft status and limited playing time in the NFL add layers of uncertainty. Howell's one-game performance, while not entirely disastrous, leaves more questions than answers, especially compared to other high-drafted QBs.

Commanders General Manager Ron Shaffer, who once remarked, "It's in the bag unless they get an offer so ridiculous they can't say no," critiques Howell's status as a mid-draft pick with limited NFL experience. He argues that placing all bets on Howell would be imprudent, given the risks involved. Howell's ceiling is predominantly that of a 'low-end starter,' a characterization that justified his fifth-round selection in 2022.

Strategically, Shaffer emphasizes the importance of balancing risk and reward. While Howell was a worthy pick, given the lower draft investment, the decision to commit fully to him based on limited evidence is a high-risk strategy. The Commanders need to consider multiple options, including other first-round prospects like Will Levis and Hendon Hooker, who could potentially offer more stability.

Conclusion: The Commanders' Dilemma

The 2023 NFL Draft offers the Commanders a unique opportunity to bolster their quarterback position. However, the decision to prioritize a QB, especially a mid-draft pick like Howell, should be carefully weighed against the available alternatives. Front offices must navigate the intricate interplay between player performance, draft status, and strategic planning to make informed decisions.

Ultimately, the Commanders must consider the long-term implications of each decision, balancing the immediate need for quarterback continuity against the broader landscape of the NFL. As NASCAR driver Dale Earnhardt Jr. once said, 'The race is not over until the checkered flag drops.' Similarly, the NFL Draft decision for the Commanders is far from definitive, leaving room for thoughtful consideration and strategic planning.