Is Neopaganism Just a Way for White People to Be Hip and Cultural Without Being Called Racist?

The age-old stereotype that all white people seek nothing but to conquer other cultures is often met with skepticism, especially when it comes to neopaganism. However, it's essential to recognize that converting to a faith such as Kemeticism is not solely motivated by a desire to appear "hip" or cultural.

The Skepticism Surrounding Neopaganism

My faith, Kemeticism, has been called problematic, especially if one only has 5% Arab descent. But let's not forget that cultural appropriation is often a two-way street. Just as Mongolians, Parsis, or Indonesians can convert to Islam or Catholicism without being labeled appropriators, why should our faith be any different? It's more problematic to assume that anyone, based on their race, would seek to convert simply to gain "hip" points or conquer a culture.

Neopaganism as a Cultural Affinity

Neopaganism, particularly Wicca, is a faith that has embraced many cultures. Why should someone be considered racist for practicing a faith that resonates with their cultural roots and offers a sense of connection to nature, something that monotheism sometimes fails to provide? It is a celebration of our polytheist and animist roots, which have always been our true cultural heritage.

The Diversity Among Practitioners

It would be naive to say that some people adopt neopaganism solely for the sake of appearing culturally hip. People convert for a myriad of reasons, as we see in other aspects of life. For example, people might engage in CrossFit not to get in shape but to appear cool, become vegan not for animal welfare but for health reasons, or support authoritarian politicians because it's the least worst choice. The same can be said for neopaganism.

Yet, there are also those who genuinely connect with the old deities and the old ways. The Old Religion speaks to various aspects of human nature, and for some, it resonates deeply, whether they are white or of any other race.

The Human Element in Faith

People express their sense of identity and connection in numerous ways, including through spiritual practices. Regardless of race or skin color, humans share a common emotional and psychological wiring. If some people find a deep affinity with the Old Religion and choose to express this affinity through their faith, it's worth respecting and acknowledging.

Examples and Data

There are quite a few people of color (POCs) engaged in contemporary paganism. For instance, the website I contribute to, The Wild Hunt, has a team of four POCs, each contributing in different ways. Would we label these individuals racist because they practice a faith that resonates with their cultural heritage? Or should we see their devotion as a natural expression of their identity?

Conclusion

While some may see neopaganism as a trendy way to appear "hip and cultural," it's crucial to recognize that the motivations behind cultural practices are complex and varied. Let us judge individuals based on the sincerity of their beliefs rather than generalized stereotypes.