Lindsey Stirling's Multifaceted Talent: Violinist, Dancer, and Innovator

Lindsey Stirling is a vocalist, violinist, and modern dancer known for her unique blend of classical music, electronic music, and dance, which has earned her a global following. While some critics may question her technical proficiency as a violinist, there's a strong case to be made that her talent lies in her ability to combine music and dance in a highly entertaining and innovative manner.

Combining Music and Dance

One of the most striking aspects of Lindsey Stirling's performances is her ability to play and dance simultaneously, a skill that not many musicians possess. This unique blend of art forms often elicits mixed reactions from the audience. While some appreciate her creative expression, others dismiss her performances as merely flailing around. Personally, I have immense admiration for her skill and dedication. It's far more challenging to walk and play an instrument simultaneously without sacrificing quality.
However, it's important to recognize that her form of music blends classical and contemporary elements in a way that has captivated millions of fans worldwide. While she may not perform the most advanced classical pieces, her unique fusion of these styles has created a distinct and appealing genre that stands on its own merit. Her ability to create engaging performances that span multiple art forms certainly sets her apart from traditional classical violins.

Technical Proficiency vs. Showmanship

Some argue that Lindsey Stirling's violin playing is not advanced enough to be compared with classical violinists like Hilary Hahn or Max Vengerov, who are considered professional in the traditional sense. While it's true that her violin playing may not be as technically refined as that of a professional classical violinist, her unique style and ability to perform in sync with her dance cannot be understated. This combination of skills, in a way, makes her stand out in her own right, earning her a special place in the hearts of her fans. In fact, her innovative approach to music-making has led to her being recognized as a "show girl" rather than just a traditional violinist.

It's also worth noting that Lindsey Stirling is an expert in social networking and marketing, which has helped her build and maintain a large following. This does not detract from her talent but rather highlights another aspect of her multifaceted career. Many recognize her as a visionary who has successfully carved out a niche in the music industry.

Professional Comparison and Personal Assessment

While I acknowledge that Lindsey Stirling's violin playing may not meet the technical standards expected from a classical violinist, her unique style and innovative approach to combining music and dance cannot be denied. Many professional violinists, such as Hilary Hahn and Max Vengerov, are noteworthy for their technical prowess, but they don't necessarily bring the same level of entertainment value. In my opinion, Lindsey Stirling scores about a 6 out of 10 in terms of technical proficiency as a violinist. Her performances often range from a "nothing special" to an "OMG she needs to stop jumping around and play the damn thing in tune". However, her efforts and dedication to her craft are commendable.

For those interested in exploring the true limits of violin playing, the works of Darrol Anger in his "Diary of a Fiddler" provide an insightful comparison. By listening to these extraordinary fiddlers, one can gain a better perspective on the gap between what Lindsey Stirling does and the top-tier players in classical music. Despite this, her work is clearly appreciated by a wide audience, and her innovative approach to music and dance continues to inspire and entertain people around the world.