Is Entertainment Always Behind Progressive Values?

The relationship between entertainment and progressive values has long been a topic of debate. It is often suggested that entertainment, especially in its commercial form, follows a fluid moral compass dictated by the prevailing social and political trends.

Defining Progressive Values

Progressive values, as some understand them, are deeply intertwined with a certain moral and ideological framework. These values are often aligned with ideals of social justice, equality, and openness. However, the concept of progressive values goes beyond mere ideological alignment; it is often tied to the pursuit of financial gain and popularity within the entertainment industry.

For instance, movements such as folk songs sung by union organizers or artists like Pete Seeger, who advocated for workers' rights and social issues, can be seen as manifestations of progressive values. However, many critics argue that certain elements of progressive culture, particularly those espoused by so-called woke activists, are more about ideology than substance.

Art as a Reflection of Values

Art, in its various forms, often serves as a reflection of society's values and ideals. Consider the performances by Pussy Riot in a Russian Orthodox Church, singing for the removal of Vladimir Putin, or Joni Mitchell's poignant lyrics: "We paved over paradise, put in a parking lot. Don’t it always seem to go that you don’t know what you’ve got until it’s gone." These works challenge conventional morality and provoke deep-thought.

Other examples like "Smiling Faces Sometimes" by The Undisputed Truth (1971) and "America's Calling Harry Truman" by Chicago (1975) demonstrate that progressive ideals are not exclusive to modern entertainment. These songs have stood the test of time, offering timeless critiques and observations.

The Role of Popular Culture

Popular culture, including movies, music, and literature, often shape public opinion and influence societal values. However, it is important to recognize that not all of it aligns with progressive ideals. For example, Mark Knopfler's "If This Is Goodbye," which reflects on the 9/11 attacks and the lives lost, offers a more somber and reflective perspective rather than a politically correct one.

Similarly, the works of Bob Dylan, iconic in the music industry, can be seen as a testament to progressive thought, albeit through the lens of honesty and truth. Dylan's songs such as "The Times They Are A-Changin'" and his later work continue to resonate with listeners seeking change and introspection.

The Dual Nature of Entertainment

Entertainment often serves as a dual-purpose medium. On one hand, it can be a powerful tool for promoting progressive values and challenging societal norms. On the other hand, it can be a reflection of the fluidity in moral values among wealthy elites.

Historically, entertainment has often been about wealth, freedom from moral constraints, and the expression of personal fantasies and desires. Therefore, it is not uncommon for some to see entertainment as serving the interests of the powerful and wealthy, rather than aligning with progressive ideals.

These wealthy elites may champion progressive values when it suits their interests, but their actions and decisions are often driven by financial gain and self-interest. This perspective is encapsulated in the idea that the entertainment industry is not inherently progressive but rather a reflection of the evolving moral landscape influenced by economic power structures.

The Dichotomy in Value Perception

The dichotomy between perception and reality is particularly evident in the treatment of certain moral issues. For instance, parents who believe in traditional family structures (mother and father) are often labeled as outdated or backward-looking by those who view themselves as progressive and open-minded.

Further, the claim that feminism has largely been about division and inequality, rather than equality, is often met with fierce backlash from those who see feminism as a pillar of progressive values. This debate highlights the complexity and variability of what constitutes "progressive values" in different contexts and among different groups.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the relationship between entertainment and progressive values is complex and multifaceted. While entertainment can promote progressive ideals, it is also a reflection of the fluidity of moral values among the wealthy and powerful. The entertainment industry, driven by commercial interests, often aligns with these values rather than purely with progressive ideologies.

Understanding these dynamics is crucial for any analysis of the role of entertainment in society and for appreciating the nuanced relationship between popular culture and progressive values.