If Johann Sebastian Bach Were Alive Today: His Musical Journey and Adaptability

Introduction

Imagine if Johann Sebastian Bach, one of the most celebrated composers in history, were alive today and had access to all the music in the world. What would he think of this endeavor? Would he still adhere to the strict baroque music principles he is known for, or would he explore new horizons?

Adaptation and Openness to Innovation

Richard Freedman, a well-known musicologist, muses over this fascinating scenario. He notes that Bach was not only a master of baroque music but also intrigued by different approaches to music and open to innovation. For instance, he was such a good friend of Telemann that he even asked him to be the godfather of one of his sons. This level of openness suggests that Bach might find it intriguing to explore contemporary music genres.

Exploring Modern Music Genres

One might imagine Bach's reaction to modern music genres like rap or electronica. Freedman considers the possibility of Bach's appreciation for modern compositions, particularly those that align with his belief in the spiritual origins of music. He believes that Bach might find that the more vertical harmonies of modern Western music complement his intertwining horizontal lines, creating a harmonious blend of old and new.

Preparation and Modern Music Guides

To help Bach understand the modern world of music, a guide like Peter Schickele would be invaluable. Schickele is known for his alter egos and his ability to bridge the gap between classical and popular music. His presence would certainly make the transition smoother for Bach, helping him acclimate to the contemporary music landscape.

Teaching and Discipline

While Bach was known for his strict disciplinarian nature, especially in his teaching, there are certain anecdotes that shed light on his gentler side. For example, there is a story where he attacked a trombone student due to a lack of practice, but such incidents might be less common in modern times. His teaching methods, however, would vastly change with modern understanding and techniques.

Potential Modern Compositions Bach Would Appreciate

Reflecting on modern compositions, it's intriguing to speculate which contemporary works Bach might enjoy. Here are a few that align well with his principles:

Samuel Barber's "Adagio for Strings"

Bach would likely appreciate the exquisite melodies and harmonies of Samuel Barber's "Adagio for Strings." This piece, which sadly Barber could not adapt from Bach's own work due to copyright issues, transports listeners to a spiritual realm with its powerful emotional impact. Its technical precision and emotive quality mirror Bach's own styles.

Carole Bayer Sager's "What a Wonderful World"

Carole Bayer Sager's and Bobby McFerrin's "What a Wonderful World" also captivates with its enduring message of peace, justice, and hope. The song's harmonies and melodies could resonate with Bach's own compositions, providing a modern twist on his traditional themes.

Conclusion

While it's impossible to know Bach's exact thoughts, the imagination of musicologists and enthusiasts like Richard Freedman offers a glimpse into what might have been. Bach's journey from baroque music to embracing new genres would be a fascinating chapter in the history of music. Whether through the guidance of contemporary composers like Peter Schickele, or through pieces like Samuel Barber's and Carole Bayer Sager's, one can only imagine the musical horizons Bach might explore.