Can Opera Singers Also Shine on Broadway?

Broadway and opera may seem like two different worlds, but there have been numerous instances where opera singers have successfully transitioned to musical theater on the Great White Way. This article explores the rich history of opera singers performing in Broadway musicals and highlights some of the most notable performers.

Notable Opera Singers on Broadway

Many opera singers have gained recognition for their performances in Broadway musicals, performing in both original cast and revival productions. Names such as Ezio Pinza, Paolo Szot, Christine Johnson, and Shirley Verrett have been instrumental in bringing their operatic talents to the stage.

Ezio Pinza

Ezio Pinza, a renowned opera singer, was part of the original cast of South Pacific. His powerful voice and distinctive baritone resonated with audiences, showcasing the versatility of operatic performers. He was not alone in this journey, with other opera singers such as Paolo Szot, who was also in the South Pacific revival, and Christine Johnson, who performed in the original cast of Carousel.

Shirley Verrett and Cesare Siepi

Shirley Verrett and Cesare Siepi, both accomplished opera singers, were part of the revival of Carousel. They brought their rich, powerful voices to the stage, further solidifying the connection between opera and musical theater.

The Multifaceted Career of Kelli O’Hara

Kelli O’Hara is a prime example of an opera-trained singer who has excelled on Broadway. Trained as an opera singer, she won a Tony Award for her role as Anna in The King and I. In addition to her role in Broadway productions, she has also performed at the Metropolitan Opera in operas such as The Merry Widow and Cosi Fan Tutte.

In 2022, Kelli O’Hara showcased her versatility by starring in a world premiere at the Met called The Hours. Moreover, she demonstrated her ability to perform both country music and opera in a parody video, proving her adaptability and excellence in multiple genres.

Other Notable Performances

Several other opera singers have made their mark on Broadway, including:

Teresa Stratas, known for her recording of Berg's opera Lulu, and for her role in the Strouse/Schwartz musical Rags. Bryn Terfel, who performed in Fiddler on the Roof. Ezio Pinza, who performed in South Pacific and Fanny. Helen Traubel, who starred in the Rodgers Hammerstein musical Pipe Dream.

Robert Weede: A Case Study

Robert Weede is another example of an opera singer who successfully made the transition to Broadway, starring in the role of Tony in the musical The Most Happy Fella on Broadway.

Challenges for Female Singers

The transition from opera to Broadway can be easier for men, especially older baritones and basses. This is evident in the number of male opera singers who have appeared in roles on Broadway, such as those in South Pacific and The Most Happy Fella.

While women can and have done the same, the roles may be less frequent. However, this does not diminish their capabilities or the importance of their contributions to the performance.

Conclusion

Opera singers have proven their versatility by transitioning to Broadway, where their powerful voices and performances have been embraced by audiences. Whether in original cast productions or Broadway revivals, these vocal maestros have brought their unique talents to the stage and continue to entertain and inspire new generations of theater-goers.