A Comprehensive Comparison of DAngelico and Guild Guitars

In the world of acoustic guitars, the choice of a DAngelico or a Guild can often be a matter of personal preference and specific requirements. Both brands offer guitars in the mid-range category, typically priced around $600 to $700, focusing on providing a balance of quality and affordability. This article delves into the differences and considerations when choosing between these two guitar brands, especially in the context of acoustic-electrics.

Overview of DAngelico and Guild Guitars

Both DAngelico and Guild are known for their high-quality guitars, built in the Far East. While they share similar construction standards, there are subtle differences in design, craftsmanship, and features that set them apart. The DAngelico brand tends to feature more modern, flashy aesthetics, with a focus on high-end models. Meanwhile, Guild has a more traditional feel, often favored by purists.

Fit and Finish

When it comes to fit and finish, both brands offer decent construction. However, some users have noted that the Gretsch Electromatic semi-hollow archtop, a competing model in the same price range, surpasses DAngelico and Guild in terms of craftsmanship. The Gretsch is known for its standout fit, playability, fret finish, and tone, making it a strong contender for the 600-ish price range.

Considerations for Flattops and Acoustic-Electrics

If you are more inclined towards flattops or are looking for acoustic-electric options, you might want to explore other brands. For instance, Eastman Blueridge and Recording King offer solid wood models that are highly rated for their sound quality and value for money.

Seagull Guitars: A Recommendation

For those seeking reliability and great sound at an affordable price, Seagull guitars are an excellent choice. Made in Canada, they are renowned for their durability and excellent tone. A used Seagull typically runs between $300 and $400, making it a cost-effective option for beginners or those looking to replace an older instrument.

Other reputable brands like Taylor and PRS (though not built in North America) also offer reasonable options within the same price range, providing a great balance of quality and value.

Guild Guitars: Historical Legacy

For those familiar with older Guild guitars, particularly from the 2000 era, they were highly regarded for their A-grade instruments. However, as with many modern manufacturers, the quality varies, with some producing grade A instruments and others producing less refined models. The author personally had a Guild from the year 2000, which required significant attention and repairs that were cost-prohibitive. It no longer met their needs due to high action affecting arthritic hands, leading to its sale.

Alternatives and Recommendations

Alvarez Masterworks MF60OM is a highly recommended solid wood acoustic-electric guitar for around $650. If you need electronics, the Alvarez MDA66CESHB offers solid wood construction with added electronics, making it a more expensive but functional option within the $800 range.

When considering a guitar in the $600 range, it's worth exploring other brands like Alhambra, known for offering solid wood models below the $1200 range. Ultimately, the best choice depends on your specific needs, budget, and personal preference. Whether you prioritize aesthetics, craftsmanship, or specific features, there's a guitar out there that fits your criteria.

Conclusion

While DAngelico and Guild offer solid options, there are numerous other brands that provide comparable or even superior features and craftsmanship within the same price range. By weighing factors such as fit, finish, sound quality, and personal style, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your musical requirements.